- What do I say to someone who is dying?
- Less than you think. Their name works. Saying you love them works, and so do thank you and I am sorry, which are the two most people leave too late. If you want to pray out loud, ask first while they can still answer. If they cannot answer and you have no reason to think they would mind, go ahead. If you know this was not their faith, or not something they would have wanted, pray silently. It is no less a prayer for their not hearing it. Talk to them rather than about them across the bed. Long speeches are usually for us, not for them.
- Can they hear me if they are unconscious?
- Nobody can tell you for certain in a particular case, though the nurses looking after them may have a view worth asking for. Hospice staff often say hearing seems to be among the last things to go. So say it anyway. If they cannot hear, you have still said it in front of God and in front of yourself, and afterwards it will matter to you that you did.
- Is it wrong to want it to be over?
- No, and the answer runs two ways. If you are the one dying and you have had enough, that is worth saying out loud to your palliative or hospice team and to whoever is closest to you. Wanting to stop is not giving up, and it is not something you have to settle alone in your head at four in the morning. Said out loud it can change what you are offered and how much pain you have to carry. If you are the one in the chair, asking God for a gentle release when someone is suffering and is not going to recover is an old prayer, not a betrayal, and people have prayed it for as long as they have sat up with the dying. Notice the difference between wanting their pain to end and wanting your own ordeal to end, and if both are in there, say both. Decisions about treatment stay with the person, their family and the medical team.
- What about someone who did not believe?
- Honestly, nobody knows. Anyone certain about where a particular person is now is telling you more than a human being can know. What has been prayed at deathbeds for centuries, across many traditions, is commendation. You put them into God's hands and you leave them there. Christians differ over whether that prayer carries on after a death. Some pray it freely, others hold that prayer is for the living, so follow your own tradition here. Either way it is not a dodge or a compromise. It is the most that can be done for anyone, including ourselves.
- Should I keep praying for a miracle?
- You can. Plenty of people do, right to the last hour, and it is not a failure of faith to stop either. Hold it loosely enough that you can still say the things that need saying now, because a goodbye cannot be postponed until you are sure. Praying for recovery and preparing for a death are not opposites. Hospice staff watch families do both in the same afternoon.